Question to the EC: EU agricultural subsidies

Question to the EC: EU agricultural subsidies

  • Wednesday, 13 November 2019

  •   A+  A-

See Francisco Guerreiro’s question to the European Commission and the written answer on EU agricultural subsidies.

Joint question by Greens/EFA MEPs Martin Häusling, Francisco Guerreiro, Sarah Wiener, Bronis Ropė, Benoît Biteau, Tilly Metz, Pär Holmgren, Anna Deparnay-Grunenberg and Molly Scott Cato.

 

Subject: EU agricultural subsidies 

A New York Times investigation, conducted in nine EU countries during much of 2019, has uncovered a subsidy system that is deliberately opaque, grossly undermines the EU’s environmental goals and is warped by corruption and self-dealing. 

The New York Times skilfully demonstrates how and why land is changing hands and how small local farmers are being displaced. Ultimately, it is only about receiving EU agricultural subsidies with mostly no binding obligations. The big beneficiaries are not concerned about the harvest or how their food is produced: they only care about receiving per-hectare subsidies. In addition, they do not manage their land in a sustainable and environmentally friendly way. 

What will the Commission do to stop this practice? 

Will it suggest, during the CAP negotiations, that information on ultimate beneficial owners be requested via the integrated administration and control system (IACS) and that the amount of money going to any one ultimate beneficial owner be capped? And how will it verify information on ultimate beneficial owners? 

Does it believe that its proposed measures on the environment, animal welfare and the climate are robust enough to stop this practice?

 

Answer in writing

 

The direct payments of the common agricultural policy (CAP) are paid for eligible land only, i.e. land used for agricultural activity or under specific commitments. The natural or legal person who can benefit from payments is the one who enjoys the decision-making power in relation to the agricultural activities and has the capacity to respect relevant requirements.

Beneficiaries must respect requirements relating to cross compliance (statutory management requirements emerging from EU legislation (including the Nitrates Directive(1)), as well as good agricultural and environmental conditions (GAEC) as adapted by Member States) otherwise their CAP payments may be reduced. They must also exercise practices beneficial for the climate and the environment to receive the ‘greening’ payment. 

The CAP is implemented in shared management. Member States must verify eligibility conditions at beneficiary level. The Commission verifies the compliance of Member States’ management and control systems and excludes non-conforming expenditure from EU financing. There is limited discretion at national level concerning decisions on the disbursement of direct payments. In the future CAP, Member States must continue to have an IACS(2), with robust controls and dissuasive penalties. Detailed rules are to be set by Member States, whereas the Commission in its supervision will focus on the compliance of Member States’ governance systems, and whether Member States can demonstrate that the expenditure incurred is matched by a corresponding reported output. 

The Commission has a zero tolerance for fraud with EU funds and takes any such allegations very seriously, ensuring that necessary steps are taken. The Commission will continue to assist Member States to further improve fraud detection and avoid conflicts of interests in the EU.

Where the lawfulness of access to land is questioned, then there is an issue of the enforceability of the national law, and the judicial system of the Member States would intervene.

For the future CAP, the Commission has proposed that ambitious rules for capping payments shall apply. The Commission has also proposed a more ambitious contribution of the CAP to the environment and climate, in particular with an enhanced conditionality replacing cross-compliance as well as with new ‘eco-schemes’ under direct payments. In accordance with the new delivery model, the Commission will verify the contribution to common EU objectives based on specific needs identified by the Member States in their national plans, in particular for environment and climate. These plans will have to reflect the ambition of the European Green Deal(3). 

(1)       Council Directive 91/676/EEC of 12 December 1991 concerning the protection of waters against pollution caused by nitrates from agricultural sources (OJ L 375, 31.12.1991, p. 1)

(2)       Integrated Administration and Control System

(3)       https://ec.europa.eu/info/strategy/priorities-2019-2024/european-green-deal_en


Share this post

To read also...

Guerreiro wants to avoid misleading use of the term “natural” on food products
  • Geral
  • Guerreiro wants to avoid misleading use of the term “natural” on food products

    Wednesday, 10 February 2021
    Under the initiative of MEP Francisco Guerreiro (Greens/EFA), MEPs want to avoid the misleading use of the term “natural” on food products and ask the European Commission to provide a clear definition of “natural” in the European Union’s food legislation.
    READ MORE
    Designer wanted! Are you up to the challenge?
  • Geral
  • Designer wanted! Are you up to the challenge?

    Wednesday, 06 January 2021
    We started the year with the search for a freelancer for a unique and paid service to improve the visual communication of my/our work in the European Parliament. All details on how to apply here.
    READ MORE
    Francisco Guerreiro: 'Without EU help, Portugal would have trouble obtaining vaccines for everyone'
  • Geral
  • Francisco Guerreiro: 'Without EU help, Portugal would have trouble obtaining vaccines for everyone'

    Tuesday, 05 January 2021
    MEP Francisco Guerreiro wants to know how much the European Commission invested in each Member State and how much Portugal saved in the acquisition of vaccines against Covid-19.
    READ MORE
    Plenary Session: EC/Mauritania Fisheries Partnership Agreement: extension of the Protocol
  • Geral
  • Plenary Session: EC/Mauritania Fisheries Partnership Agreement: extension of the Protocol

    Thursday, 17 December 2020
    See below what was discussed in this plenary session (14 to 17 december 2020) and how the MEP Francisco Guerreiro (Greens/EFA) voted.
    READ MORE
    Plenary Session: Conclusion of the EU-Japan Civil Aviation Safety Agreement
  • Geral
  • Plenary Session: Conclusion of the EU-Japan Civil Aviation Safety Agreement

    Thursday, 17 December 2020
    Brussels, 17 december 2020 - See below what was discussed in this plenary session (14 to 17 december 2020) and how the MEP Francisco Guerreiro (Greens/EFA) voted.
    READ MORE
    Plenary Session: Management, conservation and control measures applicable in the Inter-American Tropical Tuna Convention area
  • Geral
  • Plenary Session: Management, conservation and control measures applicable in the Inter-American Tropical Tuna Convention area

    Thursday, 17 December 2020
    Brussels, 17 december 2020 - See below what was discussed in this plenary session (14 to 17 december 2020) and how the MEP Francisco Guerreiro (Greens/EFA) voted.
    READ MORE
    Plenary Session: European Year of Rail
  • Geral
  • Plenary Session: European Year of Rail

    Thursday, 17 December 2020
    See below what was discussed in this plenary session (14 to 17 december 2020) and how the MEP Francisco Guerreiro (Greens/EFA) voted.
    READ MORE
    Plenary Session: Implementation of the Dublin III Regulation
  • Geral
  • Plenary Session: Implementation of the Dublin III Regulation

    Thursday, 17 December 2020
    See below what was discussed in this plenary session (14 to 17 december 2020) and how the MEP Francisco Guerreiro (Greens/EFA) voted.
    READ MORE
    Plenary Session: MFF, Rule of Law Conditionality and Own Resources
  • Geral
  • Plenary Session: MFF, Rule of Law Conditionality and Own Resources

    Thursday, 17 December 2020
    Brussels, 17 december 2020 - See below what was discussed in this plenary session (14 to 17 december 2020) and how the MEP Francisco Guerreiro (Greens/EFA) voted.
    READ MORE
    Plenary Session: A new strategy for European SMEs
  • Geral
  • Plenary Session: A new strategy for European SMEs

    Thursday, 17 December 2020
    See below what was discussed in this plenary session (14 to 17 december 2020) and how MEP Francisco Guerreiro (Greens/EFA) voted.
    READ MORE

    MORE POSTS

    Can’t find what you’re looking for?